[All right, so...clearly not a physical threat. Eliot doesn't back off, but he doesn't approach aggressively anymore, either. He just sort of stands there.]

Wait--what? Hold on--

[The guy who seems to be suffering from some kind of ailment who is obviously not a kidnapper of any sort might actually be telling the truth here.]

Seriously? You...

[He looks around, like he's expecting someone to yell out gotcha from behind a door.]

You're saying there's twenty--or more--other people around here that just...what, what are you saying, showed up here? Like--I don't even remember how I got here!